Study the chart. Use B2 comparative language: "Coal emits considerably more COโ per kWh than wind, which strongly suggests that the decarbonisation argument for renewables is substantially stronger."
For each card, note: (1) the strongest argument FOR this energy source, (2) the most significant counterargument AGAINST it.
Read the text and identify: (1) the main argument, (2) the concession made by the author, (3) three B2 persuasive phrases.
The global energy transition โ the structural shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy โ is no longer merely an environmental aspiration; it has become an economic and strategic imperative. It is clear that the cost trajectory of solar and wind power has transformed the energy landscape fundamentally: the average cost of utility-scale solar has fallen by approximately 90% since 2010, making it the cheapest source of new electricity generation in history in most markets.
Admittedly, renewables present significant challenges. Their intermittent nature โ the fact that solar panels do not generate power at night and wind turbines produce nothing when the wind does not blow โ creates genuine grid stability challenges. Furthermore, the manufacturing of solar panels and batteries requires rare minerals, raising valid concerns about supply chain sustainability and environmental impact. These concerns are legitimate; however, they are engineering challenges, not fundamental objections โ and the pace of technological innovation suggests they will be resolved.
The evidence unequivocally demonstrates that continued dependence on fossil fuels is neither environmentally nor economically sustainable. Coal plants built today risk becoming stranded assets within a decade as renewable costs continue to fall. If governments were to redirect the approximately $5.9 trillion in annual global fossil fuel subsidies towards renewable energy infrastructure, the energy transition could be substantially accelerated.
Step 1: Build 3โ4 arguments per side using the Argument Builder below. Step 2: Add at least one counterargument per side. Step 3: Run the structured debate โ 1 argument per side per round. Step 4: Award points!
It is widely acknowledged that the global energy system is undergoing an unprecedented structural transformation. It is my contention that renewables represent the only viable long-term energy future, although this position requires nuanced qualification rather than absolute advocacy.
The evidence is compelling: the cost of solar has fallen by approximately 90% since 2010, making it the cheapest source of new electricity generation in most markets. Furthermore, if governments were to redirect fossil fuel subsidies towards renewable infrastructure, global emissions would fall substantially within a decade. It is clear that the economic case for renewables now rivals โ and in many contexts, surpasses โ the environmental case.
Admittedly, renewables present challenges โ intermittency in particular. However, it should be noted that battery storage costs are falling rapidly and grid interconnection is improving. Whereas fossil fuels offer energy density and dispatchability, they impose carbon costs that are far less sustainable in the long term.
In conclusion, I largely agree that renewables represent the only viable future, although a managed transition is preferable to abrupt fossil fuel elimination. Unless investment accelerates significantly, the pace of change will be insufficient. The evidence strongly suggests that the question is not whether to transition, but how quickly.
โ Speaking: persuasive structures used? Arguments supported with data? Counterarguments structured correctly (Admittedly/However)?
โ Reading: analytical comprehension โ identifying argument/concession/evidence in text?
โ Ranking: justified with formal comparative language?
โ Bingo: engagement with debate language โ phrases ticked accurately?
โ Essay: 200 words? Correct persuasive structures + concession + conclusion?
๐ IEA โ Clean Energy Transitions
๐ UN Environment โ Energy
๐ UN SDG 7 โ Affordable & Clean Energy
๐ UN SDG 13 โ Climate Action
๐ Our World in Data โ Energy